Lakeland Office (863) 701-7411

Lake Wales Office (863) 676-1700


See what our customers have said!

Let us know how we did!

What was your experience with us?

My Family And I Love Them

I can't say enough good things about Scott Headley and his great staff. I have multiple policies with Headley Insurance. I feel like they are part of my family. We have been able to depend on them for more than 15 years. They go above and beyond the call of duty without hesitation. If your looking for insurance, look no further than Headley Insurance. My family and I love them.

Rusty Longaberger

You Are A Lifesaver

Thank you to Scott Headley and the rest of the staff at Headley Insurance Agency, for making my life SOOOOO much easier. When the Mulberry Chamber of Commerce had to research new Insurance options, you told me you would take care of it. And that you did! I would love to be able to say that it was GREAT working with you...but, I hardly call a phone call to tell you what I needed, a return call when you had it taken care of, and the signing of some papers (and a lower premium)... WORK! I REALLY appreciate your customer are a lifesaver!!

Monica DiNicolantonio

Happy Customer

I sent a Facebook message to Scott Headley (Headley Insurance Agency) at 6pm, he drove to his office, wrote the policy then drove to Regal to hand deliver it so I could drive my newly purchased truck home. Other than my parents no one has ever gone completely out of their way to this extreme. Thank you guys, you have no idea how much you have done for me. You will forever have a loyal customer.

Erika Warren

He Made It Easy!

As a business owner, I was unaware of the risk that I was exposed to. Scott Headley was able to get easy homes 123, LLC a general liability policy for my business and he also has got my rental properties covered. The service at Headley insurance was way above that I have experienced with other agents. I have referred several people already and will continue.

Steve Mitchell

Need to save On Your Insurance?

Contact a representative at Headley Insurance Agency to learn more about the benefits you can receive by combining your policies.

Lakeland Office (863) 701-7411

Lakeland Office (863) 676-1700

Lake Wales Office

Our Providers